How Does the Death of a Sibling Impact a Child?
The short answer: Deeply. We, as adults, all understand that with life also comes death. Even though we understand that, it doesn't mean we are not completely thrown when someone close to us dies. Let's now consider a child and how death has an impact on their respective lives.
As I have written previously, and spoken to various audiences about, children conceptualize death differently as they are graduated through various developmental stages. Let's take a look at what death seems to be with different age groups:
Birth-3 Years Old
-Although this age group does not understand this type of loss, they "feel" the sense of loss from their caregivers/loved ones
-Their sense of regulation is different; naptime/bedtime/feedings are different as the caregiver could be a different person or they sense a different person is providing them care
Four-Seven Years Old
-Death is seen as "reversible"; the child does not fully comprehend that the person won't "come back"
-"Magical Thinking" is exactly as it sounds: The child thinks their thoughts and/or actions had something to do with the cause of their special person's death
Eight-Twelve Years Old
-Death is seen as permanent but there is still the thought that ghosts or the "Grim Reaper" are real
-Death is felt by others but they still grapple with feeling "very alone" as "no one else has gone through this at my age."
-Their special person will not be there for future celebrations/milestones
-This can also coincide with changes in school (from primary to intermediate or intermediate to middle school) which introduces more anxiety/insecurity
Teenagers
-Children this age group understand that death is irreversible
-With this stage, kids are turning away from parents and focusing more on their peers
-As this is the case, teens are wanting to be with others who "get it." That is, they cannot view their parents as understanding how they feel because adults were "never their age."
-"What is life about?" and "Why did this happen?"
DABDA
Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, the pioneer of the hospice movement, explained grief using the acronym "DABDA" (Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance). The problem was that many took this too literally. Kübler-Ross never meant for us to take this as a linear means of grieving. We experiencing these feelings but not necessarily in a neat and orderly way. We can vacillate between these feelings. We can experience one and a month later, experience it again. For example, we can arrive at the one-year anniversary and feel as though we are back at square one. One day, we are angry and the next, in denial that they are gone. If we as adults experience this, how about children?
If we consider the developmental stage a child is in, we can then see how they are impacted by the grieving process. Just as adults experience DABDA, so do children. They will experience denial ("When is he coming home for dinner?") and anger (Why did this happen?!") and everything in between. But unlike the five emotions Kübler-Ross named, grief is a whole array of feelings. They are felt in a singular manner as well as a whole slew of emotions at one time. I compare it to the ocean water. Sometimes, grief is felt in a softer way (like gentle waves). Other times, it can feel like a tidal wave...overwhelming and difficult to escape.
What does grief look like in the developmental stages of childhood?
Zero-Three Years Old
-Fussy for what seems to be "no reason"
-Sense the feelings of caregivers and others around them
-"Clingy" with their loved ones (ex. normally can go to the neighbor's house without an issue but is now screaming when they adult caregiver is out of sight)
Four-Seven Years Old
-Talk to the deceased (ex hearing your child in the backseat of the car and they are talking to their special person)
-"Clingy"
-Change the subject (they're done talking about it but it will come up again)
-React to the grief of the adults around them; it might not seem they're "listening" in on conversations but chances are, they are
-Awaiting the person's return (remember they struggle with the concept of death at this age)
-Changes in routine can be overwhelming (ex. someone else drives to/picks up from school, child is acting out when they get in the car)
Eight to Twelve Years Old
-Physical symptoms arise (sometimes the symptoms can be related to symptoms the deceased experienced prior to death ex. headache, stomach ache)
-Acting out in school or change in grades
-"Did I do something to cause" the death?
Teenagers
-Acting out
-School issues (grades, daydreaming, attention seeking behavior)
-Use of substances
-Risky behavior
-Apathy (What's the point?)
Children who have experienced the death of a sibling also:
-Feel guilt. Yes, even though the death was sudden (like a car accident) or expected (like a long term illness), the child questions why their sibling? Why did my sibling die but I am still here (survivor's guilt)?
-Who am I? I had a brother/sister but now I don't. How do I answer when people ask me if I have any siblings?
-Keep it together in front of the parents/adults in the home because I'll make them sad
-Loneliness. I once had a playmate/confidante/friend but they are gone.
-Anger is very common. Whether the child is angry that the sibling "should have done things differently" or replaying past arguments or even the unsaid words they "should have said."
Children have difficulty expressing these feelings (much less naming them) so the adults in their lives have to help them to articulate, express, and cope with them. How can that be done?
-Be open with the child. If a child questions the death for what seems like the 100th time, it's OK to remind them of how the person died.
-Talk about their sibling. By the adults bringing up memories of the deceased sibling, the surviving child(ren) understand that it's OK to say their name and share memories.
-All feelings are OK and never wrong! That's right! No such thing as a wrong feeling. If we shut down how a child either remembers their sibling or how they feel about their sibling, we are telling the child they are wrong and to stop talking about their grief.
-Mirror for them. If we want a child to develop strong coping skills, it is vital that we show them what those mechanisms are. For example, if I feel uncomfortable crying in front of others, I hide those feelings away. Now the child sees that and begins to question if that's how people should deal with emotions. Never apologize for crying. That's telling a child, tears are bad and not to be shed in front of others. Instead, I can cry in front of my child and explain that sometimes, even though I am an adult, I feel sad too.
-Encourage drawing, journaling, and help the child identify those who they trust when they need a shoulder to cry on or lean on.
The death of a sibling has a tremendous impact on the family, including the surviving children. How we approach them and talk to them can help the child develop helpful coping skills and an understanding that they are emotionally safe with the adults who love and care for them. We can't take away their grief but we can help them to see that they have a sounding board they can trust and coping skills that will develop and mature over their lifetime.
Comments